8 ways a job interview can take a turn for the worse

So you arrive at a big job interview confident and prepared. It starts off strong. Conversation flows smoothly. You're saying all the right things. Suddenly, the hiring manager asks you a question you didn't anticipate.


The "deer in the headlights" look washes over your face. You flounder for an answer that fails to impress the hiring manager. Your confidence takes a hit, and the interview, along with any chance of getting the job, quickly head south.

Whether it's a surprise question, a wardrobe malfunction or the hour-long interview that unexpectedly turns into a day-long affair, job interviews are filled with on-the-spot situations that must be handled deftly by the candidate. If not, these situations will sink even the most prepared professional.

To help you anticipate these unexpected twists and turns, career experts and corporate recruiters shared eight situations that can come up during a job interview. They offer advice on how to navigate them gracefully so that you can get the interview back on track.

1. You're caught off-guard by an inappropriate or illegal question

By law, employers aren't allowed to ask job seekers certain questions, such as "Are you married?" or "Do you have kids?" But some hiring managers do so anyway, and these questions can throw a candidate for a loop.

Susan Whitcomb, a career coach who's authored a variety of books on career management, including Interview Magic, recommends a three-step process for answering touchy questions:

1. Avoid a direct response to an illegal question if it has the slightest chance of hurting your candidacy.

2. Address the hiring manager's underlying concern that's driving the question.

3. Accentuate a positive character trait or skill that will resound with the hiring manager.

When asked if you're married, for instance, Whitcomb suggests a job seeker reply like this: "I'm in a solid relationship. I'm blessed to have someone who supports me wholly in my career. You may wonder about my personal life and how it might affect my ability to travel and my work hours. My last position required me to work 60 hours a week and to travel once a month. I love that quiet time in the hotel at night when I can really focus on my work."

2. You need to address the dreaded "sticky wicket"

Many job candidates have a "sticky wicket" in their employment histories, such as a layoff, job-hopping or even termination with cause. Candidates who have these issues are in a particularly sticky situation. How they handle discussing their employment history can mean the difference between staying in the game and sudden-death elimination.

Bluffing your way through questions about, say, the length of your unemployment or the circumstances surrounding your departure from your last position, is out of the question, says Whitcomb. She advises job seekers to be proactive and forthright in addressing thorny employment issues. "Write out answers to those questions that you hope nobody will ask you so that you're not caught off guard and you have a positive answer to them," she says.

For example, Whitcomb suggests a job seeker, who was fired or laid off, say something like, "I just want to volunteer that in my last position, I was asked to leave. It was based on some circumstances that I have learned a great deal from. I can tell you what I've learned from the situation, how I've applied it, how it's made me a better person and a better candidate for your organization."

Rosemary Haefner, CareerBuilder's vice president of human resources, also recommends explaining what you learned from the situation and any new skills you picked up that would make you successful in the position for which you're interviewing. "You have to bring your previous experience back to why you're the best fit for the job," she says.

3. You give a ho-hum answer

No matter how much you prepare for an interview, a hiring manager is bound to ask a perfectly legal question that you never anticipated. If your mind goes blank and you muster a mediocre answer, all is not lost. You can always re-address the question later, says Connie Thanasoulis-Cerrachio, Vault.com's career expert and a former corporate recruiter with Citigroup and Warner Lambert.

She recalls a job interview when a hiring manager asked her a particularly difficult, unexpected question. Her answer was less than satisfying. But 10 minutes later, Thanasoulis-Cerrachio says, she recalled a project she had worked on that would have made for a better answer, and she asked the hiring manager if she could go back to his previous question. He said yes, and she was able to deliver a much more pointed answer.

"Answers to unexpected questions will come to you," says Thanasoulis-Cerrachio. "Sometimes you just have to relax."

4. You ramble

When job candidates don't know how to answer a question, they'll often ramble until they zero in on the answer. The risk with this strategy is that a tangent may never lead to the bull's eye.

If you find yourself prattling, stop. "There's nothing wrong with saying, 'I think I got off your train of thought. Can you restate the question?'" Thanasoulis-Cerrachio says.

Pausing to consider a question more thoughtfully shows the hiring manager that you're in control of the interview. You're also self-aware enough to know when you're not communicating effectively and must find a new way to connect with the hiring manager, says Thanasoulis-Cerrachio.

"I appreciate when candidates realize they're on shaky footing and try to get back on more stable ground," she says.

How do you know if you're rambling? Whitcomb says answers to most job interview questions shouldn't take more than two minutes to articulate. A notable exception: Behavioural interview questions may require more time to answer.

She recommends the SMART (situation, metrics, action, result, tie-in) strategy for answering interview questions, which is similar to the CAR, or challenge-action-result format. The idea is for the job seeker to talk about a situation she addressed, cite some metrics that shed light on the situation, describe the action she took as well as the result, and, lastly show how it all ties into the value she'd bring to the prospective employer.

5. You lack an important skill

An average of eight job seekers compete for every open position, Whitcomb says. Employers can afford to be picky. Chances are you don't possess all the criteria the hiring manager seeks in a candidate. This means you'll have to address your "deficiencies" during the job interview.

Find your next job with computerworld UK jobs

"Recommended For You"

IT hiring: Your text resume is soooo last century What CIOs really look for