US terror threat system ‘crippled’ by technical flaws

A $500 million (£272 million) IT project led by Boeing to prevent terrorist attacks is a failure, and cannot even handle basic search terms like "and, or and not", a US government subcommittee has said.


A $500 million (£272 million) IT project led by Boeing to prevent terrorist attacks is a failure, and cannot even handle basic search terms like "and, or and not", a US government subcommittee has said.

Allegations of waste and mismanagement were outlined in a staff memo and letter from the Subcommittee on Investigations and Oversight, part of the Committee of Science and Technology.

The bulk of the subcommittee's accusations come from a memo prepared by subcommittee staff about a data integration project called Railhead, which is intended to help intelligence and law enforcement agencies uncover terrorist plots.

Railhead, due to be ready by the end of the year, was supposed to combine and upgrade existing databases called TIDE (Terrorist Identities Datamart Environment) and improve terrorism-fighting capabilities. But the project is in such a bad shape, suffering from delays and cost overruns, that Subcommittee chairman Brad Miller said: "There may be current efforts under way to close down Railhead completely."

Miller's comment was included in a letter he wrote to Edward Maguire, inspector general for the office of the director of national intelligence. Miller wants Maguire to investigate the project.

"The end result is a current system used to identify terrorist threats that has been crippled by technical flaws and a new system that, if actually deployed, will leave our country more vulnerable than the existing yet flawed system in operation today," Miller wrote.

The subcommittee makes a case for investigation through a variety of documents it obtained, including user group meeting minutes, e-mails, internal blog postings and technical reports that raise issues with various aspects of the project. The lead system integrator for Railhead is Boeing's Space and Intelligence Systems Mission division.

Among the issues Miller wants the inspector general to probe is how Railhead is being used. His letter raises questions about money used by Boeing to renovate a building.

Railhead software was tested by the HP Quality Centre, which found that it "passed 148 tasks, but did not complete 26 others and failed 42...." Specific problems included a failure to create reports, as well as "find non-exact matches for key entities, such as a suspected terrorist's name", the memo said. "Incredibly, it also failed to demonstrate the ability to use basic Boolean search terms such as and, or and not."

The project connects dozens of data sources from a variety of agencies, using an XML platform to achieve integration. But the design team behind the effort raised concerns about the use of XML and whether it is viable. One email cited in the staff memo - from a contractor in August 2007 - expressed concerns that the XML approach could lead to integration issues. That now seems to be the case, according to Miller's letter.

The National Counterterrorism Centre issued a response to Miller's letter that called it "inconsistent with the facts." The NCTC said Miller's "letter implies that there exists a risk to our nation's security related to the implementation of NCTC's information technology program.... There has been no degradation in the capability to access, manage and share terrorist information during the life of the Railhead program."

Moreover, the NCTC statement implies that Miller's group has been out of the loop. While the intelligence agency has been giving regular updates to intelligence oversight committees, it has not given them to Miller's subcommittee.

A Boeing spokeswoman deferred comment on the matter.

"Recommended For You"

US Government's dumbest tech buys This week’s top IT projects: TfL, Metropolitan Police and Bank of England