HP-EDS deal sparks mixed end user reaction

Customers of Hewlett-Packard and Electronic Data Systems offered a range of reactions Tuesday to HP's £7.1 billion ($13.9 billion) bid for the massive outsourcing company.


Customers of Hewlett-Packard and Electronic Data Systems offered a range of reactions Tuesday to HP's £7.1 billion ($13.9 billion) bid for the massive outsourcing company.

HP will benefit from EDS' talent pool, but the spectre of layoffs -- which EDS President and CEO Ronald A. Rittenmeyer indicated Tuesday would be possible as the companies integrate -- raises concerns about customers' existing deals, said Nina Buik, president of Encompass, an HP user group that says it has 50,000 members.

"From a business perspective, I understand when you consolidate staff there's going to be duplicate jobs," Buik said. "I want to make sure the customers are still getting the level of service they signed up for. That would be my concern."

HP's pending purchase, which will bring it in close competition with services leader IBM, has been approved by both companies' boards of directors, and is expected to close in the second half of this year.

The deal will result in a new unit called "EDS -- an HP company," based in Plano, Texas, where EDS has its headquarters. Rittenmeyer will lead the new unit and report to HP CEO Mark Hurd.

Xerox has spent billions of dollars on EDS services during the past couple of decades. The company signed a $263 million deal in April that will see EDS manage and support its end-users, service desk and mainframe operations. It was a recent milestone in a long relationship.

Xerox's latest deal with EDS provides it with "flexibility in the event of changing business circumstances," and the pending acquisition could well qualify as such, said Carl Langsenkamp, director of public relations at Xerox.

However, he declined to speculate on whether Xerox would, in fact, look to alter the contract.

The company has a "two-fold relationship" with EDS, partnering with it as a member of EDS' Agility Alliance, which brings together offerings from a range of vendors into an "agile enterprise platform," he said.

Meanwhile, HP and Xerox compete in the office printing business, but Langsenkamp downplayed the potential impact. "This move seems to retrench them in IT outsourcing, but not document management," he said.

HP's hardware division presents another potential wild card for customers, should HP attempt to move EDS clients over to its computing platforms.

Hurd insisted during a conference call Tuesday that EDS would resist such an obvious temptation and remain hardware-agnostic.

This scenario is believable, Lovetere suggested.

"EDS is still a stand-alone business with a core group of customers and a core group of relationships," Lovetere said. "Trying to force customers onto platforms they don't have comfort level with doesn't make good business sense."

The acquisition will benefit both companies in the long run, said Rick Morris, chief information officer of Dollar Thrifty Automotive, which signed a five-year IT services contract with EDS worth $150 million to manage application development, network and hardware management.

"I would be more worried if they were merging with a lesser-known commodity than HP," Morris said.

With HP being a products company and much of EDS' revenue coming from infrastructure outsourcing, the acquisition is a natural way to try to expand in the services business, he said.

The combined company could lower Dollar Thrifty's IT operation cost by bringing in HP's product culture and more scale, Morris said, adding that HP could also reinforce and enable EDS' strategy to make business applications for the travel and transport industry.

Yet, there are concerns. EDS has a big focus on the travel and transportation industry, and Morris questioned whether HP would retain that vertical focus. Questions also remain about HP's ability to effectively integrate EDS' operation and culture, Morris said.

"The HP-Compaq merger seemed pretty messy; the major thought would be, would they execute this better," Morris said. HP's acquisition of Compaq for $25 billion in 2001 was considered a failure, as the company didn't generate hardware profits as a result. Former CEO Carly Fiorina, who oversaw HP's buy of Compaq, was replaced by Hurd.

The EDS deal could overall catapult HP near the top of a space worth $748 billion in 2007, according to recent figures from Gartner.

IBM led the market with about $54 billion in revenue, followed by EDS with
$22 billion. HP was in fifth place with revenue of $17 billion, behind Accenture and Fujitsu.

(Peter Sayer in Paris contributed to this report.)

"Recommended For You"

HP confirms jobs cuts as server sales slump HP and EDS: High risk say analysts