Google plans to seek Books lawsuit dismissal

Google and the plaintiffs suing it for alleged book-related copyright infringement are seemingly moving away from seeking a friendly solution, after a so-far fruitless three-year effort to settle the case.

Share

Google and the plaintiffs suing it for alleged book-related copyright infringement are seemingly moving away from seeking a friendly solution, after a so-far fruitless three-year effort to settle the case.

Google has notified the court that it intends to file a motion to dismiss parts of the lawsuit filed against it by authors and publishers in 2005, in which they allege copyright infringement stemming from Google's wholesale scanning of millions of library books without the permission of copyright owners.

It also told the District Court for the Southern District of New York that it will request as well the dismissal of a related case brought by photographers and illustrators in April 2010 objecting to the copying of their work as part of the library book scanning project.

Google stated its plan to seek the dismissals in a letter sent to Judge Denny Chin two weeks ago, and which the judge acknowledged receiving last week in a scheduling order he entered into the book-scanning case's docket.

In Chin's order, he states that Google requested a pre-motion conference prior to filing the requests for dismissal, but the judge responded that no such conference is necessary.

Instead, he set a deadline of Dec. 23 for Google to file the dismissal motions. The plaintiffs will have until Jan. 23 to respond to the motions, and Google will have to reply to the dismissal oppositions by Feb. 3, Chin wrote in the order.

 

When asked for comment, a Google representative said via email that the company told the court that it will seek dismissal of the claims "of some plaintiffs" and that it will "file a brief on that issue later this month."

The representative declined to be more specific, but the statement could mean that Google will request dismissal of the claims from the authors and from the photographers, but not from the publishers, with which Google is thought to have made more progress in settlement talks.

Although the claims are all closely related and usually addressed as a single action by those involved, there are technically three separate lawsuits in play, with the lead plaintiffs in each being the Authors Guild, the Association of American Publishers and the American Society of Media Photographers.

Exactly which plaintiffs and claims Google will challenge with its motions to dismiss will become clear at the latest by Dec. 23.

"Recommended For You"

Google fights over Books settlement Microsoft, Yahoo and Amazon 'to fight Google book deal'