Apple warranty practices now focus of EU-wide probe

Apple's warranty offerings could be pulled in the European Union after it emerged that the E.U. Justice Commissioner has asked member states to look into possible misselling.


Apple's warranty offerings could be pulled in the European Union in the wake of inquiries the EU Justice Commissioner is making into possible misleading sales practices, also known as misselling.

Earlier this week the international tech giant announced that it had stopped selling AppleCare in Italy as of November 9. Earlier this year, the company was handed a €900,000 (£725,000) fine by the Italian Antitrust Authority for not providing consumers with information regarding their EU-protected warranty rights and instead pushing their own paid-for warranty, AppleCare.

Now it has emerged that Commissioner Viviane Reding wrote to all 27 EU countries on September 21, asking them to "examine closely Apple's advertising of product warranty practices" for any similar misleading behaviour.

In Italy, Apple was warned for not putting EU mandates on its retail packaging. A disclaimer was finally added to the boxes following an unsuccessful appeal of the ruling in March.

Reding's office confirmed that she has received complaints from consumer organisations in 11 member states (Belgium, Germany, Denmark, Greece, Italy, Luxembourg, Netherlands, Poland, Portugal, Slovenia and Spain) as well as several members of the European Parliament.

Under EU consumer law, buyers are automatically entitled to a free minimum two-year warranty. Different sanctions exist in EU countries for violations of consumer protection law - for example fines, as in the case of Italy.

The Unfair Commercial Practices Directive states in part that, "member states shall lay down penalties for infringements of national provisions adopted in application of this Directive and shall take all necessary measures to ensure that these are enforced. These penalties must be effective, proportionate and dissuasive."

In Italy, Apple appears to have been so "dissuaded" that it has withdrawn the product altogether - although it is still available to buy online.

Apple said its one-year AppleCare service is superior to the EU-required two-year warranty as it includes three months' telephone support and covers defects that arise after delivery, but customers may not feel the same.

"Recommended For You"

Apple loses appeal against Italian warranty charges EU law forces Apple to highlight two-year warranty