Why is DH paying to keep Healthspace project alive?

HealthSpace, a Department of Health system for patients to keep information about their health, is to close “from” March 2013.There is evidence that the system has been failing for years, at least since a report commissioned by...

Share

HealthSpace, a Department of Health system for patients to keep information about their health, is to close “from” March 2013.

There is evidence that the system has been failing for years, at least since a report commissioned by the Department of Health and NHS Connecting for Health which, in 2010, found that the system had never worked satisfactorily. 

The Department and CfH has kept the project going, paying consultants and IT suppliers, although it was clear from an early stage that the scheme was doomed.

Why is the Department of Health continuing to pay consultants and IT suppliers for a system that is to be cancelled?

HealthSpace was designed to be a personal health organiser. It was based on a good idea - that some patients could benefit from access to their health records - but the technology was too complicated and never fit for the public to use. It is said that those involved in the project spoke in a technological, managerial and procurement language - and rarely mentioned patients.

The Guardian this week reports Charles Gutteridge, national clinical director for informatics at the Department of Health, as saying that Healthspace is “too difficult to make an account; it is too difficult to log on; it is just too difficult.”

The Department of Health later told The Guardian that Healthspace would be closed down “from” March 2013.

In 2010 a report by Trisha Greenhalgh and her team, The devil’s in the detail, which was commissioned by CfH, found that HealthSpace had involved professional advisers, software developers, security testing contractors, business managers who wrote the benefits realisation cases, lawyers who advised on privacy and regulatory matters and many others.

Yet the system was doomed from the start. Greenhalgh’s report in May 2010 revealed that:

"Project leads from participating NHS organisations repeatedly raised concerns with Connecting for Health in monthly management meetings about the low uptake of advanced HealthSpace accounts, since the benefits predicted, such as lower NHS costs and patient driven improvements to data quality, could not possibly be achieved unless the technology was used."

Comment:

It’s not known how many millions has been wasted - and continues to be wasted - on Healthspace; and it is difficult to avoid the conclusion that the continuance of the scheme benefits nobody except those who are paid to work on it, which includes contractors and IT suppliers.

Why is the scheme to be cancelled “from” 2013, when it should have been cancelled when Trisha Greenhalgh and her team produced their report in May 2010?

Shouldn’t ministers have some control - especially given that we are supposed to be in an age of public sector austerity?

In 2010 this blog had an account of how Healthspace was being kept alive unnecessarily.

Why is Healthspace kept going