Fromanetworkdiscoverystandpoint,anaccurateinventoryofdevicesthatcantechnicallysupportIPsecis
critical.Itisimportanttoknowwhichnetworkdeviceswillneedtobeupgradedforcostestimationpur-
poses,butitisjustasimportantforimplementation,sinceinmanycasesIPsecwillbreakaccesscontrollists
(ACL s)ondevicesthatdonotsupportit. Sometimesthedevicehardwarefootprintwillnotallowadevice
tofunctionproperlyunderpeakloadsinanetworkrunningIPsec,soidentifyingnetworkhardwarethatcan
receiveaRAMupgradeisimportant.Understandinghowtrafficflowsatdifferenttimescanhelpidentify
potentialweaknessesintheinfrastructurethatwillcausesignificantbottlenecksonceIPsectrafficbeginsto
flowthroughaparticulardevice.Aneffectivenetworkdiscoverysolutionwillshowwhereallofthedevices
andACLsonthenetworkarelocated,reportontheirconfigurationsandprofiles,andshowhowtraffic
flowsthroughthem.
Fromahostpointofview,understandingwhichdevicesareconnectedtothenetworkandgatheringbasic
informationabouttheiroperatingsystem,services,andconfigurationiscrucialtosuccess.Havingthisinfor-
mationallowsnetworkmanagerstounderstandtounderstandwhichversionoftheoperatingsystemis
runningonWindowsserversanddesktopsforupgradeplanningpurposes,butthisinformationisalsonec-
essarytounderstandthebasicprofilesfornon-Windowsmachines,sincethesemachinesrepresentthebulk
oftheuntrustednetwork.IPseccreatesagreatdealofoverheadthatcouldcauseperformanceproblems
foranymachineintheinfrastructurethatlackstheperformancecapabilitiestorunIPsec.Thechallengeis
topinpointthesemachines,sinceinalargenetwork,hoststendtodisappearfrommanagement.Findingand
managingthese unknownanduntrusted hostsisperhapsthegreatestsinglefactorinreducingtherisk
profileofanSD&Imigration.
CreatingVisibilitythroughNetworkDiscovery
Clearly,enterprisesneedstrongnetworkdiscoverycapabilitiestocreatethevisibilityneededtoplan,exe-
cuteandmanageaWindowsVistaSD&Iproject.Andthoughthereareanumberofapproachesonecan
taketoobtainthisdiscoverycompetency,mostareeitherunfeasibleortoopronetomistakes.Manualdis-
covery,forexample,wouldprovetootimeconsumingand,inanycase,theinevitablehumanerrorswould
significantlyincreasedelaysandcostsforanymigrationproject.Automateddiscoveryusingtraditionalnet-
workmanagementauditingtoolscanplayaroleintheultimatesolution;however,thesetoolsareinsuffi-
cientbythemselves.Mostofthesetraditionalsolutionsonlyrespondtorequestsbasedonasingleprotocol,
andwillreturnresponsesforassetsthatrespondtowhatevermanagementprotocolisbeingused.SMS,for
examplewillonlyfindhostsinWindowsdomains.WhileMicrosoftrecommendstheuseofautomateddis-
coverytools,itacknowledgestheirweaknesses: Oneproblemwithautomatedsystems,however,isthat
hoststhatareoffline,unplugged,orotherwisephysically(orlogically)unabletorespondtoqueriesforinfor-
mationwillnotshowupinthefinaldatabase.Eventhemostautomatedsystemsrequireanelementofman-
ualmanagementtoensurethatthehostsareaccessibleandaccountedforcorrectly
4
.
Amulti-protocoldiscoverytoolwillfillinmanyofthesegaps,particularlyfortheuntrustedportionofthe
network,limitingtheamountofmanualdiscoverynetworkstaffmustperform.Standardizingonadiscovery
solutionthatshowsconnectivityinadditiontoassetinventorywillfindweaknessesintheinfrastructureand
insecuritypolicythroughoutthelifeofthemigrationproject.
EMBRACINGMICROSOFTVISTAFORENHANCEDNETWORKSECURITY
4
Copyright LumetaCorporation.www.lumeta.com
4 MicrosoftSolutionsforSecurityandCompliance(MSSC),ServerandDomainIsolationusingIPSecandGroupPolicy.Microsoft
Corporation.p.45..