Rumours have been swirling for a couple of months that Beijing-based Lenovo might purchase New Tapei, Taiwan-based HTC Corporation. Following Google’s acquisition of Motorola and Microsoft’s purchase of (most of) Nokia, the move could make sense, given Lenovo’s stated strategy of becoming a “PC-Plus” company with a new focus on mobility.
As I predicted recently, there will be a forthcoming wave of industry consolidation. But what we mean by “the industry” is itself changing. My colleague Frank Gillett has been tracking this evolution for some time, having asserted in 2012 that the analytically sound way to look at operating systems combined mobile and PC OSes. There’s no separation, effectively, between PC and mobile hardware vendors. It’s one industry now.
Apple and Samsung represent the quintessential “new OEMs” in this combined computing industry, offering the trifecta of today’s key computing form factors (smartphones, tablets, and PCs) - and, in Samsung’s case, a wearable computer as well (tomorrow’s form factor). The big difference between the two companies remains operating system control - which Apple has, and Samsung doesn’t. (Let’s leave Samsung’s Bada and Tizen aside, since they’re not globally mainstream or fully developed; Samsung is tops in Android but also embraces Windows). Apple and Samsung have created a profit duopoly over mobile handset profits
So all the other PC OEMs and Mobile Handset OEMs face an important choice: How do we create ecosystems of value that span product form factors in a world where traditional PCs are either adapting or declining in sales, and mobile devices like tablets and smartphones are increasing? Lenovo is one of many companies trying to figure out this portfolio puzzle.
Lenovo has two choices on mobile: Continue its organic strategy (making its own smartphones) or purchasing a major player.
But is HTC still worth buying? Probably. Shockingly, HTC’s stock has declined 88 percent from its 2011 peak, when it enjoyed top global market share. That’s some seriously damaged goods if you only look at the stock market. But that would be too narrow a view. Leaving aside the geopolitical implications of a Chinese company buying a Taiwanese one, HTC can offer Lenovo:
- Strong product expertise. HTC has slimmed down its product portfolio to focus on the very well-reviewed HTC One device. Some even ask if it might be the best Android phone on the market, with excellent design and build quality.
- Global reach and relationships. More importantly, HTC has expertise and relationships that Lenovo, outside China, just doesn’t; as Lenovo CEO Yang Yuanqing responded when asked if Lenovo’s current success is driven mostly by China, he replied, “mostly, yes, but we are entering other emerging markets.” HTC, on the other hand, has several years of experience working with major global operators. This list includes (but is not at all limited to) Verizon and AT&T in the U.S., Vodafone, O2, and Orange in Europe, KDDI in Japan… you name the country, there’s likely a strong carrier partnership with HTC in place.
- Flashy new marketing investments. Finally, who can leave aside the fact that HTC hired Robert Downey, Jr. (“Iron Man” and Tony Stark!) for a two-year creative deal to generate new attention for the HTC brand. Surely this asset has more global cache than anything Lenovo has attempted itself since the Beijing Olympics.
Whether or not Lenovo buys HTC, both companies will need to figure out their strategies in the future combined PC-tablet-smartphone-wearables computing market. Because in terms of an industry, there can only be one.
Posted by JP Gownder, Vice President and Principal Analyst at Forrester Research.
You can follow JP on Twitter at @jgownder